Hate the Sin, Love the Sinner

2023
/
LARGE ENSEMBLE / ORCHESTRA

Details

Category
LARGE ENSEMBLE / ORCHESTRA
Price

$ 0.00 USD

Not for Sale

instrumentation

Full orchestra & electronics (2222.4331.3perc.harp.pno.strings + tape track)

duration

20'

Purchase Note

commissioned by

premiered by

Commissioned by the Grand Rapids Symphony (Marcelo Lehninger, music director).

Work composed by Nina Shekhar in 2021-2023, with accompanying video design by the composer commissioned by Grand Rapids Symphony

Program Notes

I never truly felt like a woman growing up. Being brown, I was a woman in mind, form, soul, and ambition – but never in American societal perception. Being a focus of others’ desire felt impossible for me, so I thought I myself wasn’t allowed to desire. 

The quote hate the sin, love the sinner is often taken out of context from its original meaning. Gandhi’s full quote from his 1929 autobiography is “Hate the sin and not the sinner is a precept which, though easy enough to understand, is rarely practiced, and that is why the poison of hatred spreads in the world.” If, as Gandhi writes, we are all “tarred with the same brush,” then what informs our moral judgments over another person’s identity?

As I slowly learn who I am, reclaiming my voice, body, spirit, sexuality, and agency doesn’t make me a sinner. It makes me human.

Accompanying Video Design:

(Video design by Nina Shekhar, commissioned by Grand Rapids Symphony)

Solo performance version:

Performed by Nina Shekhar on October 24th, 2023 at Princeton University; recorded by Four/Ten Media; performance, video, & lights by Nina Shekhar

Performances:

February 4th, 2022* (canceled due to COVID-19)
Grand Rapids Symphony: New World Symphony
Performed by Grand Rapids Symphony (Marcelo Lehninger, conductor)
DeVos Performance Hall, Grand Rapids, MI

February 5th, 2022* (canceled due to COVID-19)
Grand Rapids Symphony: New World Symphony
Performed by Grand Rapids Symphony (Marcelo Lehninger, conductor)
DeVos Performance Hall, Grand Rapids, MI

March 21st, 2023 (version for voice and electronics)
Tuesdays at Monk Space Presents: Nina Shekhar & Friends
Performed by Nina Shekhar
Monk Space, Los Angeles, CA

May 19th, 2023
Grand Rapids Symphony concert: Mahler’s Titan
Performed by Grand Rapids Symphony (Marcelo Lehninger, conductor)
DeVos Performance Hall, Grand Rapids, MI

May 20th, 2023
Grand Rapids Symphony concert: Mahler’s Titan
Performed by Grand Rapids Symphony (Marcelo Lehninger, conductor)
DeVos Performance Hall, Grand Rapids, MI